Maybelline Master Precise Skinny Gel Eyeliner Pencil, Defining Black, 1 Count

This is the ONLY eyeliner I'll use! I've tried from very high end to budget bargains and this eyeliner takes the cake by far! It's the most waterproof I've eved tried. It lasts all day without smudging. It's a true deep brown or jet black color depending on which you order. While I wouldn't call the eyeliners "bright," I would say the brightness comes from the vivid, consistent color and ease in which it glides on. It's matte, easy to apply, consistent, great for tight-lining, efc. This is the only eyeliner I've found that is truly waterproof, lasts all day, doesn't bleed, and is so easy to apply. Ands at THIS price point? A hidden gem!

This is the only eyeliner I use now. It goes where I want it, stays in place and is cheaper than buying at the store. Have purchased several times and will continue to do so.

I love my eyeliner to be thick and black, like my hair. This stuff is awesome. Goes on smooth, thick, dark, and dries pretty quickly. I also notice that it lasts much longer than my previous brand of eyeliner, even when I sweat or wipe my eyes. It doesn't smudge very bad either. Once it dries, it does flake a tiny bit, but not enough to be annoying. I'd definitely recommend.

Very good eyeliner just lasts so short Wish it would last a little longer But I guess for the price I can’t complain Definitely has the good quality !

This is a very precise eyeliner it is as skinny as advertised which is great. The color is a deep black which is great. The only problem is it breaks off very very easily you have to put just a tiny bit out of the applicator at a time which makes it impossible to glide across my entire eyelid in one swipe. It is nice to fill in any imperfections from when you apply a larger eyeliner.

This is my favorite eyeliner ever. My only complaint is that I use it so often it runs out quickly being so skinny. It has great staying power. It goes on very well, precise. Make sure to only twist up the tiniest amount so it doesn't break. I don't think it's waterproof but it almost is.

This eyeliner applies smooth & easily. It literally glides on the waterline and stays all day.

The pencil didn’t work the part you twist to make liner come up was stripped it just spun. Was looking forward to trying this product.