Nature Gnaws Extra Thin Bully Sticks 5-6" (10 Count) - 100% Natural Beef Chew Treats for Small Dogs

I’ve tried a lot of chews for my small, very picky Shih Tzu puppy (around 7 pounds), and these are hands down her favorite. She gets excited every single time I bring one out, and what surprised me the most is how long they last. I usually give it to her for about 30 minutes before bedtime, and she’s been working on the same stick for days now — which almost never happens with other treats. Pet pleasure: Huge win. She absolutely loves them and doesn’t want to let go. For a picky dog, that says a lot. Durability: For extra thin sticks, they last surprisingly well. Perfect for small dogs and light chewers — not too hard, but still long-lasting enough to keep them busy. Ingredients: Simple and clean — just a single ingredient (beef pizzle), which I really appreciate. Much better than heavily processed treats. Odor: There is a strong smell (as expected with bully sticks). Value for money: The pack lasts a long time, especially if you use it in shorter sessions like I do. Definitely worth it. Safety tip: I highly recommend using a bully stick holder — especially for small dogs — so they can’t swallow the last piece. It makes a big difference and gives peace of mind. Overall, this has been one of the best chews I’ve found for my puppy. Keeps her entertained, helps burn energy, and actually holds her interest — which is rare around here.

The smell of these is absolutely foul but my dog is obsessed with them as a high-value treat that he chooses above all others.

I have small dogs, and these work perfectly for them. Large chews will make them sick. I'll be buying again.

Nature Gnaws Super Skinny Bully Sticks have been a fantastic choice for my small dog, providing enjoyment without upsetting his sensitive stomach. Size and Suitability: These bully sticks are perfectly sized at 5-6 inches, making them ideal for small dogs. Unlike larger sticks, they don't cause digestive issues or diarrhea, allowing my pup to enjoy them worry-free. Quality and Enjoyment: Made from natural ingredients, these bully sticks are high-quality and safe for dogs with sensitive stomachs. My dog loves them, and they’ve become a fun part of his routine—he enjoys hiding them around the house for us to find. Frequency: We give him one every couple of days, providing just the right amount of chewing enjoyment without overindulgence. It’s a great way to keep him entertained and satisfied. Overall Experience: Nature Gnaws Super Skinny Bully Sticks are perfect for small dogs, especially those with sensitive stomachs. They offer a balance of quality, safety, and fun, making them a top choice for our household.

So I left an overall rating of 5 stars, but as far as the other questions I couldn't. Scent: 1 Star only because there's no other lower rating. Longevity: 4 Stars however that all depends on the mass of the treat. They're not all the same, which is understandable as they're natural, but the thicker the stick the longer they last. It's noteworthy to know that I switched to this type because they're more uniform and thinner than the other "variety" bags which basically have the scraps in them. They contain various sizes and she won't eat the larger pieces. VALUE FOR MONEY: 3 Stars. I get that they're all natural and all, but I feel that their prices could be a little lower than what they are now. Any salesperson will tell you that if you offer your product at a lower price, customers are prone to purchase more, ultimately leading to more profit for the company due to the increased sales overall. Getting back to the main focus here, I think that the product is GREAT and so does my 11lb Morkie (Maltese Yorkie mix). They're the perfect size for her and keep her busy for 30 - 45 minutes.